closed work permit Labour Market Impact Assessment and its importance for Permanent Residence applications
Any Canadian employer wishing to employ a temporary foreign worker (“TFW”) in Canada must first obtain authorization from the government, which is typically obtained by proving that the hiring of a TFW will not negatively impact the Canadian labour market. In most cases, the Canadian employer must apply to Employment and Social Development Canada, also known as Service Canada, for approval of the Labour Market Impact Assessment (“LMIA”), previously called a Labour Market Opinion or LMO. A LMIA is a very detailed application process that is subject to a high level of review, and must be completed without error.
Most LMIA applications require the employer to advertise the role to Canadian workers. However, certain LMIA applications are exempt from the advertising requirements. One example is the closed work permit. This category is for foreign nationals who wish to establish or purchase a business in Canada, and want to work in that business in a high-skilled position, often with the aim of immigrating permanently. To qualify as an closed work permit a foreign national must:
Demonstrate a level of controlling interest in the business, i.e. a sole or majority shareholder;
Demonstrate that his or her temporary entry to Canada will result in the creation or retention of employment opportunities for Canadians and permanent residents and/or skills transfer to Canadians and/or permanent residents; and not be in a position to be dismissed, i.e. is not in an employment position where her or she is answerable to someone more senior.
For closed work permit, no advertising or recruitment is required. The key requirement is that the foreign national owns a business in Canada in which he or she owns a controlling interest of more than 50%. Other requirements include:
A business plan that shows how the closed work permit will fund the business and create or maintain employment, and contains at least a rudimentary financial plan and timeline of events;
Active management of the business (i.e. it cannot be a passive investment) in a position that accords with the foreign national’s qualifications and experience with a wage equal to or greater than the median wage requirements for the position; and employing at least one Canadian or permanent resident (ideally in the first year as described in the business plan).
This option is available anywhere in Canada.
Once an closed work permit receives a positive LMIA, he or she can obtain a work permit from Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada equal to the validity of the LMIA (usually up to 2 years). Once a work permit is obtained, the closed work permitwill, in most cases, be in a position to apply for permanent residence through the Express Entry program.
It is worth noting that the Express Entry Comprehensive Ranking System (“CRS”) has been modified and since November 19, 2016, CRS points awarded for job offers (including those based on closed work permit) have been reduced from 600 points to either 200 points for senior managerial positions, or to 50 points. This means that an closed work permit LMIA-based work permit does not automatically guarantee an Invitation To Apply (ITA) for Permanent Residence, as it inevitably did prior to November, 2016 (although the points will still bolster the applicant’s Express Entry application). It also means that closed work permit LMIAs for senior management positions generate a substantially better chance for that person to permanently immigrate to Canada under the Federal Skilled Worker Program.